The holiday season is truly magical, isn’t it? From twinkling lights to festive songs, there’s just something special in the air. And for many families, one heartwarming tradition revolves around a timeless story: The Best Christmas Pageant Ever. This classic tale has captured the hearts of generations, making it a staple for anyone looking to share the true spirit of Christmas with their little ones. If you’re searching for the best Christmas Pageant Ever for kids, you’ve come to the right place!
This beloved story, originally a novel by Barbara Robinson, tells the uproarious and ultimately touching tale of the Herdman kids—the “worst kids in the history of the world”—who somehow end up taking over the annual church Christmas pageant. Their unconventional interpretations of the nativity story bring chaos, laughter, and an unexpected depth to the familiar tale, proving that everyone, no matter their reputation, has something valuable to contribute. It’s a powerful message about acceptance, understanding, and the true meaning of Christmas.
We’ve rounded up some of the top books, DVDs, and even some fun, related options inspired by this festive theme, ensuring you can find the perfect way to share this cherished narrative with your family. Let’s dive in and discover your next holiday tradition!
Why “The Best Christmas Pageant Ever” Resonates with Kids
What makes The Best Christmas Pageant Ever such a perennial favorite? It’s more than just a Christmas story; it’s a hilarious, honest, and profoundly moving look at human nature. Kids love the rebellious Herdman children, who shake up the usually prim and proper pageant with their raw, unfiltered energy. They learn about empathy through the eyes of the other children, who initially fear the Herdmans but slowly come to understand them. Parents appreciate the subtle lessons about not judging a book by its cover, the power of compassion, and the real meaning behind the Christmas story, often lost in commercialism. It’s truly the best Christmas Pageant Ever for kids because it makes them laugh, think, and feel.
The 7 Best Christmas Pageant Ever (and Related) Options for Kids
Here are our top picks, ranging from the original story in various formats to delightful companion pieces and fun alternatives, perfect for kids of all ages.
1. The Best Christmas Pageant Ever: A Christmas Holiday Book…
This is likely the original, iconic chapter book that started it all. Perfect for elementary and middle school readers, or as a read-aloud for younger children, this edition brings Barbara Robinson’s witty prose and touching narrative to life in its purest form. It’s a fantastic way to introduce older kids to a beloved literary classic that’s brimming with humor, heart, and important life lessons about prejudice and kindness. It’s a book that truly captures what makes The Best Christmas Pageant Ever a must-read.
- Key Features:
- Original chapter book format by Barbara Robinson.
- Engaging prose suitable for independent readers and read-alalouds.
- Timeless story that explores themes of acceptance and empathy.
- Compact and portable for holiday travels or quiet reading moments.
- Pros:
- Provides the authentic, unadulterated story.
- Encourages reading and imagination.
- Sparks wonderful family discussions about the holiday spirit.
- A nostalgic pick for parents who grew up with the story.
- Cons:
- May require some explanation for very young children regarding context.
- Black and white text might not hold attention as easily as a picture book for toddlers.
- User Impressions: Readers consistently praise this edition for its enduring charm and ability to make both kids and adults laugh out loud and shed a tear. Many recall it fondly from their own childhoods and love sharing it with new generations, calling it a true holiday tradition.
- See it on Amazon here
2. The Best Christmas Pageant Ever
This edition is often a general release of the classic story, perhaps with updated cover art or a standard paperback format, making it widely accessible. It’s the quintessential version many families pick up to start their own holiday reading traditions. Whether you’re reading it aloud chapter by chapter or your child is devouring it on their own, this book continues to be a heartwarming centerpiece of the Christmas season. It solidifies its place as the best Christmas Pageant Ever for kids due to its universal appeal.
- Key Features:
- The complete, original story without abridgment.
- Often available in various standard book formats (paperback, hardcover).
- Focuses purely on the compelling narrative and memorable characters.
- A staple for school libraries and family bookshelves.
- Pros:
- Highly accessible and often budget-friendly.
- Excellent for fostering a love of reading.
- Serves as a reliable introduction to the classic tale.
- Its humor and message are equally impactful.
- Cons:
- Might lack additional illustrations or special features found in other editions.
- The cover art can vary, so ensure it’s the edition you prefer.
- User Impressions: Customers frequently highlight this version as their go-to for gifting and personal reading. They commend its ability to resonate with readers year after year, noting how the Herdmans remain as hilarious and surprisingly tender as ever. It’s often described as a “must-have” for Christmas.
- See it on Amazon here
3. The Best Christmas Pageant Ever (picture book edition): An…
For the youngest members of your family, this picture book edition is an absolute treasure! It thoughtfully adapts Barbara Robinson’s original narrative into a more concise, visually rich format, making the story accessible and delightful for toddlers and preschoolers. With beautiful illustrations accompanying the text, it’s perfect for read-aloud sessions, allowing little ones to follow the Herdman family’s unforgettable Christmas journey with vibrant imagery. This version truly makes The Best Christmas Pageant Ever enjoyable for even the littlest kids.
- Key Features:
- Adapted for a picture book format with engaging illustrations.
- Simplified text perfect for young children and read-alouds.
- Large-format pages that make pictures easy to see.
- Retains the core message and charm of the original story.
- Pros:
- Ideal for introducing the story to very young children.
- High visual appeal helps maintain interest.
- Great for developing early literacy skills.
- Can become a cherished annual read-aloud tradition.
- Cons:
- Naturally less detailed than the full chapter book.
- Older children might prefer the original text.
- User Impressions: Parents rave about how this edition brings the story to life for their preschoolers, with many commenting on the beautiful artwork and how well the condensed text captures the spirit of the original. It’s often recommended as a first introduction to the Herdmans.
- See it on Amazon here
4. The Best Halloween Ever (The Best Ever)
While not a Christmas story, this book is by the same beloved author, Barbara Robinson, and offers a delightful, humorous take on another holiday: Halloween! If your kids adore the antics of the Herdmans and Barbara Robinson’s unique storytelling, they’ll likely find this book equally charming. It features the same irreverent humor and lovable chaos that makes her other works so popular, making it a fantastic year-round read for fans of The Best Christmas Pageant Ever. It’s a fun way to extend the “Best Ever” series beyond Christmas!
- Key Features:
- Written by Barbara Robinson, author of The Best Christmas Pageant Ever.
- Features the same memorable characters, the Herdman children.
- A humorous and chaotic take on Halloween festivities.
- Perfect for fans of the author’s distinct narrative style.
- Pros:
- Great companion read for fans of the Herdmans.
- Provides year-round entertainment from a favorite author.
- Offers a fresh, funny perspective on Halloween.
- Maintains the heartwarming undertones typical of Robinson’s work.
- Cons:
- Not a Christmas-themed story, so it won’t fit the primary holiday focus.
- Might be a surprise if readers expect another Christmas tale.
- User Impressions: Readers who love The Best Christmas Pageant Ever often discover and enjoy this Halloween counterpart, praising its similar humor and the continued adventures of the Herdman kids. It’s considered a wonderful addition for those who appreciate Barbara Robinson’s unique voice.
- See it on Amazon here
5. A Pungent Pageant The Best Christmas Fart Ever
Okay, so this one takes a very different, decidedly more… fragrant… approach to the “Best Christmas Ever” theme! Perfect for kids who love silly humor and don’t mind a bit of cheeky fun, this book promises laughs with its unique take on a Christmas pageant. It’s an imaginative and lighthearted departure from the traditional, offering a memorable, if unconventional, holiday read. If your kids enjoy books that are a bit absurd and make them giggle uncontrollably, this might just be their new favorite.
- Key Features:
- Humorous, lighthearted, and silly Christmas story.
- Likely features colorful illustrations and simple text.
- Appeals to children who enjoy toilet humor and playful narratives.
- A unique, irreverent take on the Christmas pageant concept.
- Pros:
- Guaranteed to elicit giggles and laughter.
- A fun alternative to more serious holiday stories.
- Can be a great pick for reluctant readers who enjoy humor.
- Adds a different kind of “best ever” to your collection.
- Cons:
- Definitely not the traditional heartwarming tale of the original Best Christmas Pageant Ever.
- May not appeal to all families or preferences for holiday stories.
- User Impressions: Customers report that kids absolutely adore this book, finding it hilariously funny and requesting it for repeated readings. It’s often purchased as a gag gift or for children who simply love a good, silly story, confirming its ability to bring a different kind of joy to the holiday season.
- See it on Amazon here
6. UUC The Best Christmas Pageant Ever – Loretta Swit DVD
Bring the beloved story to life on your screen with this classic DVD adaptation! Featuring Loretta Swit (known for M.A.S.H.), this live-action version allows families to watch the Herdman’s chaotic and heartwarming journey unfold visually. It’s a fantastic option for family movie night during the holidays, offering a different way to experience the narrative for those who prefer visual storytelling or for younger children who might find a chapter book too long. This DVD makes experiencing the best Christmas Pageant Ever for kids an immersive event.
- Key Features:
- Live-action film adaptation of the classic book.
- Stars Loretta Swit, adding a touch of classic appeal.
- Provides a visual interpretation of the cherished story.
- Perfect for family movie nights during the holiday season.
- Pros:
- Engages viewers of all ages with dynamic performances.
- Great for non-readers or those who enjoy seeing stories brought to life.
- A wonderful way to share a cherished memory for parents who grew up with the film.
- Adds a new dimension to understanding the characters and plot.
- Cons:
- The film’s interpretation might differ slightly from personal imagination.
- As an older production, the video quality might not be as sharp as modern films.
- User Impressions: Many viewers cherish this DVD, praising its faithful adaptation and the heartfelt performances that capture the essence of the book. It’s often cited as an annual Christmas viewing tradition, proving its lasting appeal and ability to evoke strong nostalgic feelings.
- See it on Amazon here
7. Mr. Willowby’s Christmas Tree
While not part of The Best Christmas Pageant Ever series, Mr. Willowby’s Christmas Tree is another truly delightful and classic Christmas story that beautifully embodies the spirit of giving and sharing. Written by Robert Barry, this charming tale follows a tree that, after being trimmed, brings joy to multiple families down the line. It’s a gentle, heartwarming story perfect for a cozy read-aloud session, offering a lovely message about how a small gift can spread happiness far and wide. It’s a wonderful companion to any holiday book collection.
- Key Features:
- Classic Christmas story by Robert Barry.
- Themes of sharing, generosity, and the chain of good deeds.
- Charming illustrations and simple, poetic text.
- A timeless tale perfect for young children and families.
- Pros:
- Offers a beautiful, positive message about giving.
- Calming and heartwarming for a quiet holiday moment.
- Excellent for teaching kindness and the value of sharing.
- A beloved story that holds up through generations.
- Cons:
- Not directly related to the Herdman family or the pageant theme.
- More gentle in tone compared to the humorous chaos of the pageant story.
- User Impressions: This book consistently receives high praise for its endearing storyline and the wonderful lesson it imparts. Readers love its charming illustrations and how it evokes a sense of old-fashioned Christmas magic, making it a firm favorite for many families each year.
- See it on Amazon here
Making the Most of Your “Best Christmas Pageant Ever” Experience
Once you’ve chosen your favorite version of The Best Christmas Pageant Ever for kids, there are many ways to enhance the experience and make it a truly memorable holiday tradition:
- Read Aloud: Gather the family, make some hot chocolate, and take turns reading chapters. This builds strong bonds and shared memories.
- Family Movie Night: If you opt for the DVD, pop some popcorn and enjoy a cozy movie night, discussing your favorite parts afterward.
- Discuss the Themes: Talk about the Herdmans. Why did they act the way they did? How did people’s perceptions change? What is the true meaning of Christmas?
- Create Your Own Pageant: Encourage kids to put on their own mini-Christmas pageant, perhaps with unconventional twists inspired by the Herdmans!
- Give Back: The story is all about empathy and giving. Use it as a springboard to discuss ways your family can help others during the holiday season.
No matter which option you choose, sharing a story like The Best Christmas Pageant Ever is more than just entertainment; it’s about creating lasting memories and instilling valuable lessons about kindness, understanding, and the true spirit of Christmas.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Q1: What is “The Best Christmas Pageant Ever” about?
A1: “The Best Christmas Pageant Ever” is a classic children’s novel by Barbara Robinson about the rowdy Herdman children, known as the “worst kids in the history of the world,” who unexpectedly take over the annual church Christmas pageant. Their hilariously chaotic and surprisingly heartfelt interpretations of the nativity story end up teaching everyone the real meaning of Christmas.
Q2: Why is “The Best Christmas Pageant Ever” so popular for kids?
A2: Kids love the story’s humor, the rebellious nature of the Herdman children, and how it challenges traditional expectations. It’s relatable, funny, and delivers a powerful message about acceptance and the true spirit of the holidays without being overly preachy. It’s truly a timeless and engaging read.
Q3: What age group is “The Best Christmas Pageant Ever” best for?
A3: The original chapter book is generally recommended for kids aged 8-12 (grades 3-7) to read independently, but it’s a fantastic read-aloud for younger children (ages 6+) and enjoyed by all ages, including adults. The picture book editions are perfect for preschoolers and toddlers.
Q4: Are there different versions of “The Best Christmas Pageant Ever”?
A4: Yes! Beyond the original chapter book, there are picture book adaptations for younger readers, play scripts for stage productions, and even a live-action TV movie adaptation available on DVD. This article highlights several of these options, ensuring there’s a format for every family.
Q5: Can “The Best Christmas Pageant Ever” be used in schools or churches?
A5: Absolutely! The story is widely used in schools and churches as a popular Christmas play, due to its strong themes of compassion, understanding, and the true meaning of the nativity. Many school and church groups perform the stage adaptation each year.
Q6: What are some of the main themes in “The Best Christmas Pageant Ever”?
A6: Key themes include judging others, acceptance, empathy, the true meaning of Christmas (beyond commercialism), and how understanding and compassion can transform even the most challenging situations. It encourages readers to look beyond appearances and embrace differences.
Q7: Is there a movie version of “The Best Christmas Pageant Ever”?
A7: Yes, there is a beloved live-action TV movie adaptation of “The Best Christmas Pageant Ever” that first aired in 1983, starring Loretta Swit. This movie remains a cherished part of many families’ holiday traditions and is available on DVD.
Conclusion
Whether you’re a longtime fan of the Herdman family’s chaotic charm or discovering them for the first time, The Best Christmas Pageant Ever continues to be a heartwarming and hilarious story that reminds us what the holidays are truly about. From the original chapter book to charming picture book adaptations, and even the classic DVD, there are so many ways to enjoy this classic. And don’t forget the fun, related reads that expand on the author’s humor or offer alternative festive delights!
We hope this guide helps you pick the absolute best Christmas Pageant Ever for kids (or a wonderful companion story!) to share with your family this season. Happy reading, happy watching, and most importantly, happy holidays!